Da sind wir.

Sentence Discussions German
#1

I don’t understand when to use da and when to use hier on these without context. I feel like I’m just blindly guessing. Can anyone help?

1 Like
#2

Well, I don’t know if this helps but here is at least an attempt :smiley:

hier = here if you’re referring to a place you are at. Hier lebe ich, Wir sind hier

da = there if you’re referring to a place you’re not at. Da bin ich (photo), Das Museum ist da

Now a little bit more specific - this explanation does not work in the special case you’re mentioning. I think this use of da is best explained by saying that you’re basically still using it out of the perspective from which you started. Like, you’re leaving the train from Frankfurt to Marseille and you’re still talking from the perspective you’ve had in Frankfurt. Honestly, it’s the only way I found to make any sense of it. Luckily this is not really important - it’s not that natural to say hier sind wir in the scenario I described but you would still be understood.

#3

Hmm, still a bit confusing (the last part, not the here/there part; I get that fine)… Thanks for trying to explain. I assume it’s something I’ll start to get by feel over time, which is the whole point of this! :slight_smile: Thanks!

1 Like